| October |
| | 29 | 7:00PM | McKendree | @ | Trinity International University | 99-79 | |
| | 30 | 7:30PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Blue Mountain College | 70-98 | |
| November |
| | 1 | 4:00PM | Lyon College | @ | Williams Baptist | 78-70 | |
| | | 4:00PM | McKendree | @ | Mid-Continent College | 80-72 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Vennard College | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 65-81 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Concordia Seminary-St. Louis | @ | Columbia | 31-104 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Baptist Bible College | @ | William Woods | 50-84 | |
| | 3 | 7:00PM | Culver-Stockton College | @ | William Woods | 60-75 | |
| | | 7:30PM | Columbia | @ | Avila University | 81-74 | |
| | 4 | 7:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Graceland University | 77-81 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Union University | 70-120 | |
| | 5 | 7:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | University of Saint Francis | 81-60 | |
| | Coach Kevin Gamble's 100th career victory. | |
| | | 7:00PM | McKendree | @ | Lindenwood University | 82-77 | |
| | 6 | 5:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Iowa Wesleyan College | 72-77 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | Missouri Valley College | 64-75 | |
| | 7 | 5:30PM | Columbia | @ | Central Bible College | 78-47 | |
| | | 6:00PM | William Woods | vs. | Bellevue University | 59-91 | |
| | Mount Mercy College Tournament | |
| | | 7:00PM | Ohio Dominican University | @ | McKendree | 86-88 | |
| | 8 | 2:00PM | William Woods | vs. | Judson College | 81-86 | |
| | Mount Mercy College Tournament | |
| | | 4:00PM | Logan Chiropractic | @ | Missouri Baptist | 75-79 | |
| | MBU Homecoming | |
| | | 4:00PM | William Jewell College | @ | Harris-Stowe | 76-61 | |
| | | 4:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Lyon College | 70-76 | |
| | | 5:00PM | Columbia | @ | Evangel University | 69-63 | |
| | | 6:00PM | Concordia University | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 60-51 | |
| | 10 | 7:00PM | Saint Ambrose University | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 64-79 | |
| % | 11 | 7:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Illinois State University | 57-81 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Missouri Valley College | @ | Harris-Stowe | 85-59 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Culver-Stockton College | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 67-81 | |
| | | 7:00PM | McKendree | @ | Park | 64-79 | |
| | 12 | 7:00PM | Central Methodist University | @ | William Woods | 77-72 | |
| | 13 | 7:00PM | Central Christian College | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 68-91 | |
| | | 7:30PM | Blue Mountain College | @ | Williams Baptist | 78-90 | |
| | 14 | 6:00PM | Missouri Baptist | vs. | Avila University | 70-82 | |
| | Lindenwood Classic | |
| | | 7:00PM | Culver-Stockton College | @ | Columbia | 75-83 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Ecclesia College | @ | Williams Baptist | 65-63 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Indiana University-South Bend | @ | McKendree | 61-75 | |
| | McKendree Classic | |
| | | 7:00PM | University of St. Mary | @ | William Woods | 73-85 | |
| | 15 | 7:00PM | Trevecca Nazarene University | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 67-77 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Lincoln University | 69-93 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Union University | @ | McKendree | 83-80 | (OT) |
| | McKendree Classic | |
| | | 7:30PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Quincy University | 50-67 | |
| | | 8:00PM | Missouri Baptist | vs. | Lindenwood University | 101-93 | |
| | Lindenwood Classic | |
| | 18 | 7:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Olivet Nazarene University | 70-69 | (OT) |
| | | 7:00PM | Central Baptist College | @ | Williams Baptist | 75-71 | |
| | | 7:30PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Missouri Valley College | 47-72 | |
| | | 7:30PM | William Woods | @ | College of the Ozarks | 60-62 | |
| | 19 | 7:00PM | Mid-Continent College | @ | McKendree | 70-89 | |
| | 20 | 7:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Missouri-St. Louis | 59-88 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Principia College | @ | William Woods | 51-85 | |
| | 21 | | University of Illinois at Springfield | vs. | Valley City State University | 76-64 | |
| | Viterbo Classic, Nov. 21-22, LaCrosse, WI | |
| | | 4:00PM | Williams Baptist | vs. | Temple Baptist College | 91-72 | |
| | Bethel College Classic | |
| | | 5:30PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | vs. | Bethel College | 67-87 | |
| | Iowa Wesleyan Classic - Nov. 21-22 | |
| | | 6:00PM | Columbia | @ | William Carey University | 85-86 | (OT) |
| | 22 | 1:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | vs. | Briarcliff College | 69-73 | |
| | Iowa Wesleyan Classic - Nov. 21-22 | |
| | | 2:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Henderson State | 92-90 | |
| | | 2:00PM | Williams Baptist | vs. | Tennessee Temple | 80-74 | |
| | Bethel College CLassic | |
| | | 3:00PM | Avila University | @ | William Woods | 69-67 | |
| | | 4:00PM | Missouri Valley College | @ | Missouri Baptist | 61-68 | |
| | | 4:00PM | McKendree | @ | Benedictine College | 57-72 | |
| | | 4:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Viterbo University | 64-52 | |
| | Viterbo Classic Championship Game | |
| | | 5:00PM | Columbia | vs. | Graceland University | 81-55 | |
| | 24 | 7:30PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Truman State University | 51-68 | |
| | 25 | 7:00PM | Saint Xavier University | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 85-89 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Culver-Stockton College | @ | Harris-Stowe | 54-66 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Columbia | @ | Missouri Valley College | 73-60 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Christian Brothers University | 63-99 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Brescia University | @ | McKendree | 63-75 | |
| | | 8:00PM | William Woods | @ | Central Methodist University | 62-69 | |
| | 28 | | Missouri Baptist | vs. | University of Missouri-Rolla | 75-87 | |
| | University of Missouri - St. Louis Classic | |
| | | 6:00PM | Baker University | vs. | Harris-Stowe | 91-67 | |
| | Columbia College Tournament | |
| | | 6:00PM | McKendree | vs. | Freed-Hardeman University | 79-80 | |
| | Union University Thanksgiving Classic | |
| | | 8:00PM | Sterling College | @ | Columbia | 74-85 | |
| | 29 | | Missouri Baptist | vs. | Missouri-St. Louis | 56-86 | |
| | University of Missouri - St. Louis Classic | |
| | | 1:00PM | Sterling College | vs. | Harris-Stowe | 86-91 | (OT) |
| | Columbia College Tournament | |
| | | 3:00PM | Baker University | @ | Columbia | 46-74 | |
| | | 4:00PM | Iowa Wesleyan College | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 79-87 | |
| | | 4:00PM | McKendree | @ | Union University | 67-66 | |
| | Union University Thanksgiving Classic | |
| December |
| | 1 | 7:00PM | Mid-Continent College | @ | William Woods | 68-56 | |
| | 2 | 7:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Lambuth University | 65-68 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | St. Louis College of Pharmacy | 75-60 | |
| | 3 | 7:00PM | Park | @ | Missouri Baptist | 92-87 | |
| | 4 | 7:00PM | Olivet Nazarene University | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 77-67 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Ecclesia College | 66-71 | |
| | 5 | | Missouri Baptist | vs. | Robert Morris College | 82-83 | |
| | College of the Ozarks Tournament | |
| | 6 | | Missouri Baptist | vs. | College of the Ozarks | 68-70 | |
| | College of the Ozarks Tournament | |
| % | | 3:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Southwest Baptist | 66-112 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Park | @ | McKendree | 76-78 | |
| | 8 | 7:30PM | Missouri Valley College | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 72-62 | |
| | 9 | 7:00PM | McKendree | @ | Olivet Nazarene University | 78-75 | (OT) |
| | McKendree's Harry Statham wins game No. 975 and ties Jim Phelan as the all-time leader in games coached at the four-year level | |
| | 11 | 7:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Robert Morris College | 96-100 | |
| | 12 | | Missouri Baptist | vs. | Cornerstone University | 92-89 | |
| | Grace College Tournament | |
| | | 6:00PM | Harris-Stowe | vs. | Central Baptist College | 62-71 | |
| | Bethel College Tournament | |
| | 13 | | Missouri Baptist | vs. | Notre Dame College | 70-63 | |
| | Grace College Tournament | |
| | | 3:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Saint Ambrose University | 75-70 | |
| | | 3:00PM | Columbia | @ | Park | 76-80 | |
| | | 3:00PM | Concordia Seminary-St. Louis | @ | Williams Baptist | 51-96 | |
| | | 4:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Drury University | 59-89 | |
| | | 6:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Bethel College | 72-85 | |
| | Bethel College Tournament | |
| | 16 | 7:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Victory University | 71-93 | |
| | | 7:00PM | McKendree | @ | Concordia Seminary-St. Louis | 70-48 | |
| | McKendree coach Harry Statham becomes the all-time leader for games coached at the four-year collegiate level, all divisions (1,355 games) | |
| | | 7:00PM | William Woods | @ | Missouri Valley College | RAIN | |
| | 19 | 12:00PM | Benedictine College | @ | Columbia | 63-74 | |
| | 23 | 3:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Saint Xavier University | 81-74 | |
| | 29 | | Missouri Baptist | vs. | Northwood University | 70-71 | |
| | Northwood University Tournament | |
| | 30 | | Missouri Baptist | vs. | Illinois Wesleyan | 72-82 | |
| | Northwood University Tournament | |
| | | 3:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Oklahoma City University | 75-97 | |
| | | 3:00PM | McKendree | @ | Ohio Dominican University | 63-59 | |
| January |
| | 2 | 4:00PM | William Woods | vs. | Brescia University | 59-75 | |
| | Columbia College Tournament | |
| | | 8:00PM | Graceland University | @ | Columbia | 58-79 | |
| | 3 | 3:00PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | Park | 68-71 | |
| | | 4:00PM | William Woods | vs. | Graceland University | 73-84 | |
| | Columbia College Tournament | |
| | | 8:00PM | Brescia University | @ | Columbia | 73-70 | |
| | 6 | 3:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Central Baptist College | 55-105 | |
| * | 8 | 7:30PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | Harris-Stowe | 75-67 | (OT) |
| * | | 7:30PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Williams Baptist | 82-67 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Columbia | 55-91 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | William Woods | @ | McKendree | 69-74 | |
| * | 10 | 4:00PM | McKendree | @ | Missouri Baptist | 80-72 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 67-81 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 68-70 | |
| | 13 | 7:00PM | Concordia Seminary-St. Louis | @ | Harris-Stowe | 34-77 | |
| | 15 | 7:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Park | 67-76 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | Columbia | 84-81 | (OT) |
| * | | 7:30PM | McKendree | @ | Harris-Stowe | 76-62 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | William Woods | @ | Williams Baptist | 85-67 | |
| * | 17 | 4:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Missouri Baptist | 64-93 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Columbia | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 63-60 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | William Woods | 79-97 | |
| * | 20 | 7:30PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 63-71 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Williams Baptist | 81-56 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | McKendree | @ | Columbia | 68-65 | |
| | 21 | 7:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Saint Louis College of Pharmacy | 76-48 | |
| * | 22 | 7:30PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 59-83 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Columbia | @ | William Woods | 60-77 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Williams Baptist | @ | McKendree | 68-84 | |
| * | 24 | 4:00PM | William Woods | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 61-87 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Columbia | 51-93 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | McKendree | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 68-65 | |
| | 27 | 7:00PM | Robert Morris College | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 85-82 | |
| | 29 | 7:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Champion Baptist | CNCL | |
| * | | 7:30PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Missouri Baptist | 77-58 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Columbia | @ | Harris-Stowe | 70-57 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | William Woods | 75-60 | |
| * | 31 | 4:00PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | William Woods | 94-75 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | McKendree | 74-82 | |
| | McKendree's Eric Palm scores a season-high 36 points to lead the Bearcats to their 12th consecutive win | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Harris-Stowe | 63-49 | |
| February |
| | 2 | 7:00PM | Missouri Valley College | @ | Columbia | 49-73 | |
| * | 5 | 7:30PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Missouri Baptist | 45-65 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Columbia | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 60-44 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | McKendree | @ | William Woods | 66-46 | |
| * | 7 | 4:00PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | McKendree | 56-76 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Harris-Stowe | 87-75 | |
| | | 4:00PM | Park | @ | Columbia | 62-63 | |
| | 9 | 7:00PM | William Woods | @ | Missouri Valley College | 57-82 | |
| * | 10 | 4:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Williams Baptist | 79-81 | |
| | | 7:00PM | Saint Louis College of Pharmacy | @ | Harris-Stowe | 46-60 | |
| * | 12 | 7:30PM | Columbia | @ | Missouri Baptist | 65-59 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | McKendree | 61-86 | |
| | Bearcats collect their 15th consecutive win | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Williams Baptist | @ | William Woods | 55-79 | |
| | 13 | 7:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Culver-Stockton College | 56-50 | |
| * | 14 | 4:00PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | Williams Baptist | 74-70 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Columbia | 75-86 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | William Woods | @ | Harris-Stowe | 72-81 | |
| | 17 | 7:00PM | Park | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 83-92 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | Missouri Baptist | 64-60 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Harris-Stowe | 90-86 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Columbia | @ | McKendree | 53-55 | |
| * | 19 | 7:30PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 83-71 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | William Woods | @ | Columbia | 58-61 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | McKendree | @ | Williams Baptist | 71-52 | |
| | McKendree clinches AMC regular-season title for second consecutive year | |
| * | 21 | 4:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | William Woods | 81-53 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Columbia | @ | Williams Baptist | 82-60 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | McKendree | 64-77 | |
| | Coach Harry Statham earns career win No. 990; Bearcats win 18th consecutive game | |
| * | 23 | 7:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 54-83 | |
| | 26 | 7:00PM | Champion Baptist | @ | Williams Baptist | CNCL | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 58-71 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Columbia | 40-70 | |
| * | | 7:30PM | William Woods | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 54-65 | |
| * | 28 | 4:00PM | William Woods | @ | Missouri Baptist | 52-53 | |
| * | | 4:00PM | McKendree | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 80-69 | |
| | McKendree wins its 19th consecutive game and finishes AMC play with a 14-0 record | |
| * | | 4:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 57-72 | |
| March |
| | 5 | 7:00PM | Harris-Stowe | @ | McKendree | 50-79 | |
| | AMC Men's Basketball Tournament -- Quarterfinal Round | |
| | | 7:00PM | Williams Baptist | @ | Columbia | 88-89 | |
| | AMC Men's Basketball Tournament -- Quarterfinal Round | |
| | | 7:00PM | William Woods | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | 61-74 | |
| | AMC Men's Basketball Tournament -- Quarterfinal Round | |
| * | | 7:00PM | Missouri Baptist | @ | Hannibal-LaGrange | 70-71 | |
| | AMC Men's Basketball Tournament -- Quarterfinal Round | |
| | 7 | 4:00PM | Hannibal-LaGrange | @ | McKendree | 63-79 | |
| | AMC Men's Basketball Tournament -- Semifinal Round | |
| | | 4:00PM | University of Illinois at Springfield | @ | Columbia | 79-84 | |
| | AMC Men's Basketball Tournament -- Semifinal Round | |
| | 10 | 7:00PM | Columbia | @ | McKendree | 65-54 | |
| | AMC Men's Basketball Tournament -- Championship | |
| | 19 | 2:15PM | Columbia | vs. | Lee University | 72-69 | |
| | 2009 Buffalo Funds-NAIA Division I Men's Basketball National Championship -- First Round | |
| | | 8:00PM | McKendree | vs. | Northwestern Oklahoma State University | 83-58 | |
| | 2009 Buffalo Funds-NAIA Division I Men's Basketball National Championship -- First Round | |
| | 20 | 6:15PM | Columbia | vs. | Union University | 84-64 | |
| | 2009 Buffalo Funds-NAIA Division I Men's Basketball National Championship -- Second Round | |
| | | 9:45PM | McKendree | vs. | Texas Wesleyan University | 87-75 | |
| | 2009 Buffalo Funds-NAIA Division I Men's Basketball National Championship -- Second Round | |
| | 21 | 6:00PM | Columbia | vs. | Westminster College of Salt Lake City | 50-47 | |
| | 2009 Buffalo Funds-NAIA Division I Men's Basketball National Championship -- Quarterfinals | |
| | | 8:00PM | McKendree | vs. | MidAmerica Nazarene University | 55-59 | |
| | 2009 Buffalo Funds-NAIA Division I Men's Basketball National Championship -- Quarterfinals | |
| | 23 | 9:00PM | MidAmerica Nazarene University | vs. | Columbia | 56-60 | |
| | 2009 Buffalo Funds-NAIA Division I Men's Basketball National Championship -- Semifinals | |
| | 24 | 9:00PM | Rocky Mountain College | vs. | Columbia | 77-61 | |
