| School | AMC | Overall | GB | Streak | ||
| Columbia | 12-2 | .857 | 40-10 | .800 | -- | Won 3 |
| William Woods | 10-4 | .714 | 31-22 | .585 | 2.0 | Lost 1 |
| Missouri Baptist | 9-5 | .643 | 28-17 | .622 | 3.0 | Lost 2 |
| Williams Baptist | 7-7 | .500 | 31-10 | .756 | 5.0 | Lost 1 |
| McKendree | 7-7 | .500 | 24-18 | .571 | 5.0 | Lost 1 |
| Illinois at Springfield | 6-8 | .429 | 15-20 | .429 | 6.0 | Lost 2 |
| Harris-Stowe | 4-10 | .286 | 6-24 | .200 | 8.0 | Lost 8 |
| Hannibal-LaGrange | 1-13 | .071 | 2-24 | .077 | 11.0 | Lost 3 |

