| School | AMC | Overall | GB | Streak | ||
| Columbia | 16-0 | 1.000 | 41-5 | .891 | -- | Lost 2 |
| Missouri Baptist | 12-4 | .750 | 23-15 | .605 | 4.0 | Lost 1 |
| William Woods | 10-6 | .625 | 19-16 | .543 | 6.0 | Lost 1 |
| Illinois at Springfield | 10-6 | .625 | 17-22 | .436 | 6.0 | Lost 1 |
| McKendree | 9-7 | .563 | 18-17 | .514 | 7.0 | Lost 1 |
| Williams Baptist | 7-9 | .438 | 27-11 | .711 | 9.0 | Lost 1 |
| Hannibal-LaGrange | 5-11 | .313 | 15-23 | .395 | 11.0 | Lost 1 |
| Harris-Stowe | 3-13 | .188 | 7-21 | .250 | 13.0 | Lost 2 |
| Stephens | 0-16 | .000 | 10-25 | .286 | 16.0 | Lost 9 |

