All-Sports Trophies
The Presidents’ Cup is awarded to the institution accumulating the most points, determined by final regular-season standings in the 17 conference championship sports. The Valerie Beeson Women’s Sports Championship Trophy and the Lowell Pitzer Men’s Sports Championship Trophy are awarded to the institution accumulating the most points, determined by the final regular-season standings of women’s and men’s championship sports.
Points are awarded in a manner that the Conference champion receives five times the number of teams sponsoring each sport, each subsequent team receives five fewer points than the team finishing above it (with the last-place team earning five points). Should teams tie in the final standings, the total number of available points among the tied spots will be combined then divided by the number of tied teams.
| Year | Presidents Cup Winner | Beeson Trophy Winner | Pitzer Trophy Winner |
| 2025-26 | |||
| 2024-25 | Columbia College | Columbia College | William Woods University |
| 2023-24 | Columbia College | Columbia College | Columbia College |
| 2022-23 | Columbia College | ||
| 2021-22 | Columbia College | ||
| 2020-21 | Columbia College | ||
| 2019-20 | COVID-19 - Not Awarded | ||
| 2018-19 | Columbia College | ||
| 2017-18 | Columbia College | ||
| 2016-17 | Columbia College | ||
| 2015-16 | William Woods University | ||
| 2014-15 | William Woods University | ||
| 2013-14 | William Woods University | ||
| 2012-13 | William Woods University | ||
| 2011-12 | William Woods University | ||
| 2010-11 | McKendree University | ||
| 2009-10 | McKendree University | ||
| 2008-09 | McKendree University | ||
| 2007-08 | McKendree University | ||
| 2006-07 | McKendree University | ||
| 2005-06 | McKendree University | ||
| 2004-05 | McKendree University | ||
| 2003-04 | McKendree University | ||
| 2002-03 | McKendree University | ||
| 2001-02 | McKendree University | ||
| 2000-01 | McKendree University |